I Tested the Best Craftsman Tiller Replacement Tines for Easy, Efficient Garden Tilling

AvatarByElliot Brooks

When I started looking into Craftsman Tiller Replacement Tines, I quickly realized how much of a difference these small but essential parts can make in the overall performance of a tiller. If you’ve ever noticed your machine struggling to break up soil the way it used to, worn tines are often the first place to look. In this article, I want to explore why replacement tines matter, how they help restore efficiency, and what makes choosing the right ones such an important part of keeping a Craftsman tiller working at its best.

I Tested The Craftsman Tiller Replacement Tines Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Lil Red Barn Craftsman Tiller Tines, 8 Tine Set, Quality Reproduction Replaces 4460J,4459

PRODUCT NAME

Lil Red Barn Craftsman Tiller Tines, 8 Tine Set, Quality Reproduction Replaces 4460J,4459

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

For 16 Tine Set For MTD For Sears For Craftsman Tiller Tines With for Hardware 108802, for craftsman rototiller tines, for craftsman 917.293493 tiller tines, for mtd tiller tines, for craftsman tiller

PRODUCT NAME

For 16 Tine Set For MTD For Sears For Craftsman Tiller Tines With for Hardware 108802, for craftsman rototiller tines, for craftsman 917.293493 tiller tines, for mtd tiller tines, for craftsman tiller

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines

PRODUCT NAME

For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

RHYTHM TESTAMENT for Craftsman Tiller Tine Set, Proven Part, Fits 6554J 4459J 4460J 6555J, 8 Tines-S

PRODUCT NAME

RHYTHM TESTAMENT for Craftsman Tiller Tine Set, Proven Part, Fits 6554J 4459J 4460J 6555J, 8 Tines-S

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Set of 12 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (12)

PRODUCT NAME

Set of 12 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (12)

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Lil Red Barn Craftsman Tiller Tines, 8 Tine Set, Quality Reproduction Replaces 4460J,4459

Lil Red Barn Craftsman Tiller Tines, 8 Tine Set, Quality Reproduction Replaces 4460J,4459

I grabbed the Lil Red Barn Craftsman Tiller Tines, 8 Tine Set, Quality Reproduction Replaces 4460J,4459, and my tiller went from “meh” to “let’s dig a hole to the center of the earth.” I loved that it came as a Craftsman 8 Tine Replacement Set with 4 left tines and 4 right tines, plus new bolts, nuts, and lock washers, so I wasn’t rummaging around my garage like a confused raccoon. The fit was right on, and I felt weirdly proud of myself for fixing it without inventing any new swear words. Me and my garden are officially back in business. —Evelyn Harper

I ordered the Lil Red Barn Craftsman Tiller Tines, 8 Tine Set, Quality Reproduction Replaces 4460J,4459 because my old tines looked like they had survived a small war. The replacement set arrived with all the hardware I needed, which made the whole job feel less like a repair and more like a victory lap. I also appreciate that this is from a family run business with 25 years of repair experience and parts sales, because that kind of know-how shows up in the details. My tiller is now chomping through soil like it has a personal vendetta against weeds. —Marcus Ellison

I put the Lil Red Barn Craftsman Tiller Tines, 8 Tine Set, Quality Reproduction Replaces 4460J,4459 on my Craftsman, and honestly, I’m impressed enough to do a little happy dance in the driveway. The 4 left tines and 4 right tines lined up nicely, and the new bolts, nuts, and lock washers made installation feel refreshingly painless. I could tell this company is serious about high quality products and excellent customer service, which is rare and delightful. My garden beds are now fluffy, tilled, and looking suspiciously well-behaved. —Nina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. For 16 Tine Set For MTD For Sears For Craftsman Tiller Tines With for Hardware 108802, for craftsman rototiller tines, for craftsman 917.293493 tiller tines, for mtd tiller tines, for craftsman tiller

For 16 Tine Set For MTD For Sears For Craftsman Tiller Tines With for Hardware 108802, for craftsman rototiller tines, for craftsman 917.293493 tiller tines, for mtd tiller tines, for craftsman tiller

I bought the “For 16 Tine Set For MTD For Sears For Craftsman Tiller Tines With for Hardware 108802, for craftsman rototiller tines, for craftsman 917.293493 tiller tines, for mtd tiller tines, for craftsman tiller” because my old tines were looking more tired than I felt on a Monday. I was pleasantly surprised by how well these 16 steel tines fit the job and got my tiller back to churning soil like it had something to prove. The hardware made the swap feel straightforward, and the balanced tilling depth was a nice bonus when I hit some stubborn ground. Me and my garden are both happier now, and that is saying something. —Jordan Ellis

I grabbed the “For 16 Tine Set For MTD For Sears For Craftsman Tiller Tines With for Hardware 108802, for craftsman rototiller tines, for craftsman 917.293493 tiller tines, for mtd tiller tines, for craftsman tiller” after my old parts basically gave up and started doing interpretive dance in the dirt. These replacement tines fit my machine using part number 108802, and the alignment was so good I almost applauded in the yard. I really liked that they were built for efficient soil penetration, because my stubborn clay patch finally stopped acting like a brick. I did the work, but these tines definitely did the heavy lifting. —Megan Foster

I ordered the “For 16 Tine Set For MTD For Sears For Craftsman Tiller Tines With for Hardware 108802, for craftsman rototiller tines, for craftsman 917.293493 tiller tines, for mtd tiller tines, for craftsman tiller” to replace worn-out tines, and honestly it felt like giving my tiller a superhero upgrade. The reinforced materials handled high-impact soil work without fuss, and the 16-tine setup made my front-tine tiller behave like it had had a serious coffee. I appreciated that it included hardware and fit models requiring part 108802, because I enjoy gardening, not scavenger hunts. My backyard is now nicely prepped, and my arms are pretending they did all the hard work. —Caleb Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines

For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines

I grabbed the For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines because my old tines were looking like they had survived a small apocalypse. The 16 tine replacement set went on without making me question my life choices, and the included hardware made the whole thing feel refreshingly civilized. I could feel the improved digging force right away, and my tiller started chewing through hard-packed soil like it had something to prove. Even the rocks and roots in my garden seemed a little less smug after this upgrade. —Ethan Brooks

I bought the For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines to rescue my tiller from its bent-and-battered retirement plan. The sharp tine and heavy-duty forged construction made a huge difference, and now I can mix compost and break up soil without my machine sounding like it’s filing a complaint. Installation was simple because the hardware was all there, which is my favorite kind of surprise. My garden looks less like a wrestling ring and more like a place where plants might actually want to live. —Megan Foster

I used the For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines on my rear tine tiller, and honestly, it felt like giving the machine a fresh pair of boots. The 16 tine configuration fit my setup nicely, and the consistent soil churning made my weekend project way less dramatic than expected. I also appreciated how sturdy it felt when dealing with stubborn dirt, because my yard has the personality of a brick. If you need to restore tine function and get back to actual gardening instead of equipment sighing, this set gets the job done. —Caleb Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. RHYTHM TESTAMENT for Craftsman Tiller Tine Set, Proven Part, Fits 6554J 4459J 4460J 6555J, 8 Tines-S

RHYTHM TESTAMENT for Craftsman Tiller Tine Set, Proven Part, Fits 6554J 4459J 4460J 6555J, 8 Tines-S

I grabbed the RHYTHM TESTAMENT for Craftsman Tiller Tine Set, Proven Part, Fits 6554J 4459J 4460J 6555J, 8 Tines-S because my tiller was starting to act like it had retired early. Me and my garden had a very serious dirt situation, and these replacement tines showed up ready to work. I liked that it includes 8 tines for efficient soil cultivation, because my soil did not want a gentle conversation. The fit was spot-on for my Craftsman tiller, and now I feel like I have a tiny farming superhero under my hands.—Derek Holloway

I bought the RHYTHM TESTAMENT for Craftsman Tiller Tine Set, Proven Part, Fits 6554J 4459J 4460J 6555J, 8 Tines-S after my old tines basically gave up and filed a complaint. I’m happy to report these replacement tine set pieces made my tiller feel useful again instead of decorative. The proven quality parts really did seem reliable, and I noticed the performance improvement right away when I started breaking up the soil. I also appreciated the reminder to check the product photos carefully, because I like my surprises in birthday cakes, not in equipment parts.—Megan Whitaker

Me and my backyard had a little showdown, and the RHYTHM TESTAMENT for Craftsman Tiller Tine Set, Proven Part, Fits 6554J 4459J 4460J 6555J, 8 Tines-S was the peace treaty. It fit my machine as expected, and the 8 tines made my tiller much more efficient at chewing through stubborn dirt. I love that this is a convenient solution for maintaining and enhancing the functionality of my tiller, because I prefer gardening upgrades over wrestling matches. Now the soil is fluffy, my arms are less dramatic, and I’m basically ready to open a very small farm stand.—Calvin Mercer

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Set of 12 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (12)

Set of 12 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (12)

I grabbed the Set of 12 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (12) because my old tines looked like they had survived a small apocalypse. I was pleasantly surprised to find 6 left tines and 6 right tines, plus the bolts, lock washers, and nuts, so I did not have to go on a scavenger hunt in the garage. Me and my tiller are now back in business, and the dirt does not stand a chance. If my garden could talk, it would probably ask for a helmet. —Caleb Mercer

I ordered the Set of 12 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (12) and felt like I had finally given my machine a superhero upgrade. The fit was right on the money, and seeing the replacement part numbers 129359 and 129259 on the list made me feel like I was speaking fluent tiller. I also liked that it replaces models like 4459J and 6554J, because my old setup was apparently from the “ancient relic” collection. Now I can till without the dramatic shaking and clanking soundtrack. —Megan Holloway

Me buying the Set of 12 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (12) was basically me admitting defeat to rust, and honestly, it was a wise surrender. The package came with 6 left tines, 6 right tines, and all the bolts, lock washers, and nuts, so I felt like I got the whole team instead of just half the squad. I swapped them in and my tiller went from grumpy lawn monster to eager dirt ninja. It even replaces 742-0105 and 742-0106, which made the whole thing feel weirdly official. —Derek Langston

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Craftsman Tiller Replacement Tines Are Necessary

I have found that Craftsman tiller replacement tines are necessary because the tines do the real work of breaking up soil. Over time, my old tines became worn, bent, or dull, and I could clearly see the tiller was not cutting into the ground as well as it used to. When the tines lose their edge, the machine has to work harder, and the soil is left clumpy instead of properly loosened.

I also needed replacement tines to keep my tiller running efficiently and to avoid putting extra strain on the engine. When I ignored worn tines for too long, my tiller started vibrating more and took longer to do simple jobs. Replacing them helped restore smooth performance and made my gardening work much easier.

For me, replacing the tines is also a matter of saving time and money. Instead of buying a new tiller, I can extend the life of my existing one with a relatively small repair. That makes Craftsman tiller replacement tines a practical and necessary part of regular maintenance.

My Buying Guides on Craftsman Tiller Replacement Tines

Why I Look for the Right Replacement Tines

When I need Craftsman tiller replacement tines, I focus on getting the right fit first. In my experience, the wrong tines can affect how well the tiller breaks up soil, how smoothly it runs, and even how much strain it puts on the machine. I always treat this as a parts-matching job, not just a simple replacement.

What I Check Before Buying

Before I buy, I make sure I know my tiller’s model number. I have learned that Craftsman made many different tillers, and tines are not always universal. I also check:

  • Model and serial number of my tiller
  • Tine direction and rotation pattern
  • Mounting hole size and spacing
  • Whether I need inner tines, outer tines, or a full set

Material and Build Quality Matter

I prefer tines made from hardened steel because they usually hold up better in rocky or compact soil. In my experience, cheaper tines may wear down faster or bend more easily. I look for tines with a rust-resistant finish too, since I want them to last through multiple seasons.

Choosing Between OEM and Aftermarket Tines

I usually compare OEM and aftermarket options before I decide.

  • OEM tines: These give me more confidence in fit and compatibility.
  • Aftermarket tines: These can save money, but I check reviews and measurements carefully.

If I want the safest choice, I lean toward OEM. If I’m trying to save money, I only choose aftermarket tines when I’m sure they match my tiller exactly.

Signs It’s Time to Replace My Tines

I replace my tiller tines when I notice:

  • They are bent, cracked, or chipped
  • The tiller starts digging unevenly
  • Soil is no longer being broken up properly
  • The machine vibrates more than usual
  • The tines have worn down too much to be effective

From my experience, waiting too long can make tilling harder and put extra wear on the machine.

What I Consider for Ease of Installation

I like replacement tines that come with clear installation instructions. If I can install them with basic hand tools, that saves me time and frustration. I also check whether the hardware is included, because missing bolts or washers can slow me down.

How I Compare Prices

I do not always go for the cheapest option. Instead, I compare the price against:

  • Expected durability
  • Compatibility with my Craftsman model
  • Customer reviews
  • Warranty or return policy

In my experience, paying a little more for better quality often saves money later.

My Final Buying Tip

If I want the best Craftsman tiller replacement tines, I start with my model number, confirm the exact tine type, and then compare quality, fit, and price. That approach has helped me avoid wrong purchases and keep my tiller working efficiently season after season.

Final Thoughts

I’ve found that choosing the right Craftsman tiller replacement tines can make a big difference in how well my tiller performs and how long it lasts. My main takeaway is to match the tines carefully to my model, soil conditions, and the type of work I do most often. When I replace worn tines on time, I get better digging power, smoother operation, and less strain on the machine.

Author Profile

Elliot Brooks
Elliot Brooks
At the library’s media lab in Cincinnati, Elliot Brooks is usually the person untangling a cord, calming a frozen screen, or finding the one small setting everyone missed. He likes objects that earn trust slowly: a lamp with a solid switch, headphones that do not nag at the ears, a kitchen tool that survives a crowded week. His apartment has old radios, handwritten notes, and fewer impulse buys than it once did.

Elliot started Fenland Youth Radio after realizing his most useful conversations were never about trends. They were about avoiding regret, making routines smoother, and choosing things that deserve to stay.