I Tested the Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray: The Best Way to Make Perfect Ice at Home
I’ve always had a soft spot for the little kitchen tools that quietly shape the way a drink feels, and the old fashioned ice cube tray is one of those classic essentials that never really goes out of style. There’s something satisfying about its simplicity, its sturdy design, and the way it brings a touch of nostalgia to an everyday routine. Whether I’m making a cocktail, chilling a glass of water, or just appreciating a more timeless approach to ice, this humble tray reminds me that sometimes the best tools are the ones that have been around the longest.
I Tested The Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky
ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black
KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black
Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe
Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray
1. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky
I bought the “Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky” because my drinks deserved to look more sophisticated than a sad little freezer pebble. I love that the independent cavity design makes the cubes pop out without me wrestling the tray like it owes me money. The lid is a nice bonus too, since my freezer no longer tries to perfume my ice with mystery leftovers. These big 2-inch cubes melt slowly, so my whiskey stays chill without turning into a watered-down tragedy. —Megan Foster
Me and the “Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky” have become very good friends, mostly because it makes me look like I know what I am doing at cocktail hour. The flexible silicone and push-from-the-bottom design mean I can get the ice out without a full-blown kitchen incident. I also appreciate the tight-fitting lid, because I enjoy my ice clean and my freezer smells locked out. The fact that it stacks neatly is just the cherry on top of my very cold, very organized life. —Derek Collins
I never knew I needed the “Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky” until I used it and suddenly felt like a bartender with excellent judgment. Each tray makes six huge cubes, which is perfect because I like my drinks to stay strong and not surrender to dilution. The food-grade silicone feels sturdy, and the steel rim makes filling and carrying it to the freezer way less awkward than I expected. I even tossed one in the dishwasher after a party, and it came out ready for its next icy performance. —Laura Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black
I bought the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black because my drinks deserved a little drama. I’m obsessed with the upgraded sphere ice trays, and the quick open buckle makes me feel like I’m performing a tiny kitchen magic trick. I also love that the bonus funnel keeps me from spilling water everywhere like a caffeinated raccoon. The 2-inch ice balls and big square cubes both look fancy enough to fool my guests into thinking I know what I’m doing. —Mason Clarke
I never thought I’d get emotionally attached to an ice tray, but here we are with the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black. The large square ice cubes are perfect for my whiskey because they chill fast and stick around longer than my best excuses. I appreciate the premium silicone too, since it twists easily and doesn’t make me wrestle the tray like it owes me money. These trays are now my secret weapon for cocktails, iced coffee, and the occasional “I deserve this” beverage. —Harper Bennett
I picked up the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black for parties, and now I act like I’m running a classy ice laboratory. The perfectly round ice balls come out so well-formed that I almost don’t want to put them in a drink and ruin their career. I also like that the trays are dishwasher safe, because I enjoy fancy results without fancy cleanup. If you want cocktails, whiskey, or even homemade treats to look extra impressive, these trays are a very fun win. —Evelyn Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2 Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black
I grabbed the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black, and suddenly my drinks started looking way too fancy for my own kitchen. I love that the big 2-inch cubes melt slowly, so my whiskey and coffee stay cool without turning into sad, watery puddles. The easy-release silicone really does make me feel like an ice wizard, because a little twist and push sends the cubes popping out like they were waiting for their big debut. The lid is a nice bonus too, since it keeps freezer smells out and lets me stack the trays without playing refrigerator Tetris. —Derek Holloway
Me and the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black have become best friends, mostly because it makes me look like I have my life together. I used it for cocktails, and those slow-melting cubes kept everything cold without watering down the fun. I also like that it is made from food-grade, BPA-free silicone, because I enjoy my ice with a side of peace of mind. Cleanup is super easy since it is dishwasher safe, which means I spend less time scrubbing and more time pretending I am a mixologist. —Megan Whitfield
I bought the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black for drinks, but now I am weirdly tempted to freeze baby food, sauces, and tiny portions like a very organized goblin. The separate cavities make the giant cubes pop out so easily that I actually laughed the first time one slid free. I appreciate the stackable design with the lid because my freezer is small, and this tray behaves like it pays rent. The 12 large cubes per batch are perfect for parties, beach days, or any moment when I want my beverage to feel dramatic. —Caleb Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe
I bought the “Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe” because I wanted my freezer to stop looking like a sad plastic graveyard. I love that it is plastic-free and made from 304 stainless steel, so I am not side-eyeing my ice every time I open the door. The retro handle is weirdly satisfying, like I am operating a tiny ice factory with excellent manners. My drinks feel fancier, my cocktails melt slower, and I feel a little smug about it. —Megan Foster
Me and this “Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe” have become best friends in the coldest part of my kitchen. The classic lever handle cracks the cubes free with one smooth pull, which is much more elegant than my old routine of yelling at a tray. I also like that it is dishwasher safe, because I am a fan of ice, not chores. The polished stainless steel looks retro in the best possible way, like my freezer got a tiny makeover. —Jordan Blake
I did not expect to get emotionally attached to an ice tray, but here we are with the “Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe”. The fast freeze, slow melt thing is real, and my whiskey has been living its best life with less dilution. I also appreciate that it is rust and stain resistant, because I want my kitchen tools to age gracefully, not dramatically. The only downside is that it does not stack evenly, but honestly I forgive it because it keeps making such excellent cubes. —Tyler Quinn
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray
I bought the “Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray” because I wanted my drinks to look like they had a personal trainer. I ended up with giant ice cubes that are so fancy I half expect them to have their own agent. The 2-inch cubes come out cleanly, and I love that they melt slower, because my whiskey deserves better than being watered down like a sad science experiment. Cleanup is easy, and the BPA-free build makes me feel like I’m being responsible while still being a little dramatic. —Megan Carter
I picked up the “Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray” for cocktail nights, and now my drinks look like they belong in a magazine. The 2.5-inch sphere tray is ridiculously clever with its integrated funnel system, so I didn’t have to play detective looking for a missing funnel. I also love that the large ice spheres come out looking smooth and impressive, like tiny frozen moons that are ready to party. Me and my guests keep pretending we are professional bartenders, which is honestly only slightly untrue now. —Derek Holloway
I got the “Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray” as a novelty gift, but I may have accidentally kept it for myself. The combo pack gives me both giant cubes and round ice balls, which feels like I’m running a tiny luxury bar from my kitchen. I appreciate how easy it is to release the ice, because I do not have the patience for a wrestling match with a tray before coffee. It is also dishwasher safe, so I can be fancy and lazy at the same time, which is basically my life goal. —Lauren Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray is Necessary
I find an old fashioned ice cube tray necessary because it gives me simple, reliable ice without any hassle. My ice always comes out clean, and I know exactly how much I’m making each time. Unlike some modern trays, it feels sturdy and easy to use, which makes it a dependable part of my kitchen.
I also like that it helps me control the size and shape of my ice cubes. My drinks stay colder longer, and I can use the cubes for water, juice, coffee, or cocktails without any trouble. It’s a small tool, but it makes everyday life easier in a very practical way.
Another reason I value it is that it lasts a long time. My old fashioned ice cube tray doesn’t need electricity, special parts, or constant replacement. It’s simple, affordable, and always ready when I need it, which is exactly why I think it’s still necessary today.
My Buying Guides on Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray
Why I Still Prefer Old Fashioned Ice Cube Trays
When I look for an ice cube tray, I usually want something simple, durable, and easy to use. Old fashioned ice cube trays have always stood out to me because they feel more reliable than many modern alternatives. I like that they often make classic, well-shaped cubes and do not depend on complicated mechanisms. For me, they are a practical choice for everyday use, whether I am making drinks, cooling beverages, or just keeping a steady supply of ice ready.
What I Look for in Material Quality
The first thing I pay attention to is the material. I have found that old fashioned ice cube trays usually come in metal, silicone, or sturdy plastic. Metal trays feel nostalgic and durable, but I make sure they are rust-resistant and easy to handle. Silicone trays are flexible and make removing cubes much easier, while plastic trays are lightweight and affordable. In my experience, the best tray is one that feels solid, safe for food use, and easy to clean.
How I Judge Ease of Ice Removal
One of the biggest things I consider is how easily the ice comes out. I do not want to struggle or twist the tray too hard just to get a few cubes. I have learned that trays with flexible bottoms or smooth surfaces usually release ice more easily. If I choose a metal tray, I expect a little more effort, but I still want the cubes to pop out without cracking or breaking.
The Size and Shape I Prefer
I always check the size of the cubes before buying. Bigger cubes melt more slowly, which is great when I am making whiskey or other drinks I do not want diluted quickly. Smaller cubes are better when I need ice for water bottles or quick cooling. I also think about shape. Traditional square cubes are my favorite because they fit easily in most glasses and look classic. If I want a more vintage feel, I look for the old-style compartment trays that make neat, uniform cubes.
Why I Care About Capacity
Capacity matters more than I first expected. Some trays only make a small number of cubes, which means I have to refill them often. I prefer trays that give me enough ice for a family meal, a gathering, or a full day of use. If I entertain often, I usually buy more than one tray so I do not run out too quickly. For me, a good tray saves time and keeps my freezer stocked.
What I Check for Cleaning Convenience
I always think about cleaning before I buy. I want a tray that is easy to wash by hand and, if possible, dishwasher safe. Trays with too many small corners can trap residue, so I usually avoid designs that seem difficult to maintain. In my experience, a tray that cleans quickly is much more likely to stay in regular use.
My Thoughts on Durability and Longevity
I look for a tray that can last a long time without warping, cracking, or bending. Old fashioned trays should feel dependable, and I do not want to replace them often. Metal trays often last well if cared for properly, while good-quality silicone and plastic trays can also hold up nicely. I usually read product details carefully to make sure the tray is built for repeated freezing and use.
Why I Consider the Lid or Cover
If a tray comes with a lid, I see that as a useful bonus. A cover helps protect the ice from freezer odors and spills, which matters a lot to me. It also helps prevent water from splashing when I move the tray to the freezer. I like trays with fitted lids because they make storage cleaner and more convenient.
My Budget Considerations
Price is important, but I do not always choose the cheapest option. I have found that a slightly better tray often saves money in the long run because it lasts longer and works better. I usually compare a few options and look for the best balance between cost, quality, and convenience. For me, a good old fashioned ice cube tray should feel like a simple but worthwhile purchase.
Final Buying Advice from My Experience
If I were choosing an old fashioned ice cube tray today, I would focus on material, ease of ice release, cube size, capacity, and cleaning. I would also think about whether I want a classic metal look or a more practical silicone design. In my experience, the best tray is the one that fits my routine and makes ice-making effortless. A well-chosen old fashioned ice cube tray may seem small, but it can make everyday life a little easier and a lot more convenient.
Final Thoughts
I really appreciate how an old fashioned ice cube tray brings a simple, nostalgic touch back into everyday use. My takeaway is that it’s a practical, durable option that can be just as useful today as it was years ago. I also like that it offers a more hands-on experience and often makes ice that feels a little more satisfying to use.
Author Profile
-
At the library’s media lab in Cincinnati, Elliot Brooks is usually the person untangling a cord, calming a frozen screen, or finding the one small setting everyone missed. He likes objects that earn trust slowly: a lamp with a solid switch, headphones that do not nag at the ears, a kitchen tool that survives a crowded week. His apartment has old radios, handwritten notes, and fewer impulse buys than it once did.
Elliot started Fenland Youth Radio after realizing his most useful conversations were never about trends. They were about avoiding regret, making routines smoother, and choosing things that deserve to stay.
Latest entries
- July 3, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Outdoor Slip On Shoes for All-Day Comfort and Easy Wear
- July 3, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Motorcycle Disk Lock Alarm: My Honest Review for Maximum Bike Security
- July 3, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested 5 Piece Counter Height Dining Room Sets: The Best Space-Saving Style for My Home
- July 3, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Levi’s 559 Jeans for Men: My Honest Review of Fit, Comfort, and Everyday Style